Protecting Prudent Investment of Retirement Savings Act
Click any stage to learn more about the legislative process.
The bill would amend the main federal pension law, ERISA, to require retirement plan fiduciaries to base investment decisions solely on financial factors rather than environmental, social, or other non-financial goals, with narrow exceptions and new documentation requirements.
It would also bar discrimination in selecting plan service providers, set new rules for voting proxies tied to retirement plan stock, and require new disclosures when 401(k)-style plans offer self-directed brokerage windows, reshaping how ESG investing is handled in employer retirement plans nationwide.
What this bill would do
What it would do
The bill would amend the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) in four parts. It would require plan fiduciaries to base investment decisions solely on "pecuniary" (financial) factors, with an exception allowing non-pecuniary factors as a tiebreaker if documented, and allowing certain participant-directed plans to offer investment options that promote non-financial goals under conditions. It would bar discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, or national origin when selecting or retaining plan fiduciaries, counsel, or service providers. It would require fiduciaries to vote proxies and exercise shareholder rights solely in participants' financial interest, while clarifying that not every proxy must be voted, and would let fiduciaries adopt safe-harbor voting policies. Finally, it would require new participant notices and a GAO study when 401(k)-type plans offer brokerage windows outside the plan's designated investment menu. It does not ban ESG funds outright but restricts when non-financial factors may drive investment or proxy decisions, and sets delayed effective dates for each division.
Key provisions
- 1Would require fiduciaries to base investment decisions solely on pecuniary factors, with a documented exception allowing non-pecuniary tiebreakers and limited use in participant-directed plans
- 2Would prohibit discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, or national origin when selecting, monitoring, or retaining plan fiduciaries, counsel, or service providers
- 3Would require fiduciaries to exercise shareholder rights and vote proxies solely in participants' economic interest, and would allow safe-harbor voting policies
- 4Would require specific notices to participants before directing investments into brokerage windows not designated by plan fiduciaries
- 5Would define "designated investment alternative" to exclude brokerage windows and self-directed accounts
- 6Would require a GAO report comparing investment returns in brokerage windows versus designated plan investment options
Who would be affected
Fiduciaries and administrators of employer-sponsored retirement plans covered by ERISA, including 401(k) and pension plan sponsors, investment managers, proxy advisory firms, and the millions of workers and retirees whose retirement accounts are managed under these plans. Service providers, counsel, and employees selected by plans would also be affected by the new nondiscrimination rule.
Why it matters
The bill would reshape how retirement plan managers can weigh ESG and other non-financial considerations in investment and proxy-voting decisions, a contested issue in the retirement industry. Plan participants could see changes in available investment options and proxy voting practices, while fiduciaries would face new documentation, disclosure, and monitoring obligations and potential liability exposure.
What would change
Changes to existing law
Amends Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, Section 404(a) (Sec. 1002)
Adds a rule requiring fiduciary investment decisions to be based solely on pecuniary factors, with limited documented exceptions
Amends Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, Section 404(a)(1) (Sec. 2002)
Adds a requirement that fiduciaries select, monitor, and retain service providers without discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, or national origin
Amends Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, Section 404 (Sec. 3002)
Adds a new subsection governing fiduciary duties when exercising shareholder rights and voting proxies, including safe-harbor policies
Amends Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, Section 404(c) (Sec. 4002)
Adds notice requirements participants must receive before directing investments into non-designated brokerage window arrangements
Amends Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, Section 3 (Sec. 4002)
Adds a definition of "designated investment alternative" excluding brokerage windows and self-directed accounts
Agencies directed to act
Effective dates
- Limitation on non-pecuniary factors in fiduciary investment decisions
- New shareholder rights and proxy voting requirements
- Brokerage window disclosure notice requirement
- GAO study on brokerage account returns due to Congress
Funding and costs
Congressional Budget Office estimate
CBO estimates that enacting H.R. 2988 would have no effect on net direct spending or revenues over the 2025–2035 period, with discretionary spending increases of less than $500,000 over 2025–2030.
CBO and the Joint Committee on Taxation estimate that H.R. 2988 would not affect net direct spending or revenues over the 2025–2035 period, nor would it increase on-budget deficits in any of the four consecutive 10-year periods beginning in 2036. The bill would increase spending subject to appropriation (discretionary spending that Congress must separately fund each year) by less than $500,000 over 2025–2030, reflecting minor administrative costs to implement the new fiduciary standards. CBO found that the bill imposes private-sector mandates — including requirements that fiduciaries vote proxies solely for beneficiaries' financial benefit and that pension plans warn participants about brokerage-window investment risks — but estimates the compliance costs would not exceed UMRA's annual private-sector threshold ($206 million in 2025); the bill contains no intergovernmental mandates.
How implementation would work
Plan fiduciaries would need to document their reasoning when using non-pecuniary factors, adopt written proxy-voting policies (including optional safe harbors based on ownership thresholds), and periodically review those policies. Plans offering brokerage windows would have to deliver a standardized four-part notice, including a projected-balance illustration, before each investment directed outside the plan's designated menu. The Department of Labor would be the implied enforcer of these ERISA fiduciary standards, while the Comptroller General must report to Congress within two years comparing brokerage-window and designated-alternative investment returns.
Legislative status & sources
Latest action
Received in the Senate and Read twice and referred to the Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions.
Official CRS summary
Show the CRS summaryHide the CRS summary
This bill modifies the requirements for fiduciaries of employer-sponsored retirement plans.
First, the bill generally requires a plan fiduciary to make investment decisions based solely on pecuniary factors (i.e., factors that a fiduciary prudently determines are expected to have a material effect on the risk or return of an investment based on appropriate investment horizons consistent with the plan's policies and objectives).
The bill allows nonpecuniary factors to be considered in certain situations, such as when selecting investment options for certain participant-directed retirement plans or if the fiduciary is unable to distinguish between investment alternatives on the basis of pecuniary factors alone.
The bill also prohibits a plan fiduciary from discriminating when selecting, monitoring, and retaining any fiduciary, counsel, employee, or service provider of the plan.
The bill requires a plan fiduciary to act solely and prudently in accordance with the interests of the plan's participants and beneficiaries when exercising a shareholder right (e.g., voting of proxies). However, the fiduciary duty to manage shareholder rights does not require the voting of every proxy or the exercise of every shareholder right.
Finally, the bill requires a plan fiduciary to provide specified notices with respect to a pension plan that provides a participant or beneficiary the opportunity to select from designated investment alternatives.
Legislative subjects
Business ethics; Employee benefits and pensions; Financial services and investments; Labor and Employment
Committee report
H. Rept. 119-421